Roy Halladay shakes hands with Ruben Amaro Jr. AP Photo Cliff Lee traded to Seattle MarinersIt was the boldest "baseball move" that Ruben Amaro Jr., in his second off-season as the Phillies general manager, could make. Adding a Cy Young caliber pitcher like Roy
Halladay and subsequently trading away
Cliff Lee in a separate deal to make up for the lost prospects needed to acquire Halladay. However you may feel about the overall impact of the decision making process, the bottom line is that the Phillies have added perhaps the best pitcher in baseball to their roster in Halladay.
Let us get down to the basic details of the series of trades that combine to form the blockbuster off-season deal.
The Phillies acquired Roy Halladay from Toronto in exchange for
Kyle Drabek,
Michael Taylor and Travis d'Arnaud. Toronto immediately traded Taylor to Oakland in exchange for Brett Wallace. The Phillies also acquired
Phillippe Aumont,
J.C. Ramirez and outfielder
Tyson Gillies from the Seattle Mariners in exchange for Lee.
With Halladay, who Amaro has been in pursuit for since as early as 2008, the Phillies obtain a front line ace for the starting rotation. Halladay should be the favorite to be the team's opening day starter, which would set up
Cole Hamels as the number two pitcher, followed by either
JA Happ or
Joe Blanton.
Jamie Moyer will likely start the season as the team's fifth starter. After dominating American League lineups for his entire career Halladay could be considered a favorite to win the National League Cy Young Award.
In order to complete the deal Halladay was signed by the Phillies until 2013 with an option for 2014. Reports indicate that Halladay will receive up to $20 million per season in that time.
The three prospects coming from Seattle in the highly debated Lee trade appear to be promising. They may not be as high caliber as Drabek and Taylor, who were shipped to Toronto, but they do help replenish the farm system with prospects who are on track to reach the majors down the line for the Phillies.
Filling the farm system, under the Phillies' recent strategic methods of building the team, was a necessity. Trading Lee to acquire worthwhile prospects was the only way to go about it. Lee's contract is up at the end of the 2010 season and it was very unlikely that the Phillies would have been able to keep him in town. This is why Amaro made a move to bring in Halladay, considered a better pitcher, and worked out an extension in the process for what will likely turn out to be a cheaper deal than Lee will receive on the free agent market.

Many fans in Philadelphia feel that the Phillies should have kept Lee in addition to Halladay but financially that just was not possible. The club has stated time and time again that they can not afford to go too far over $140 million and having Lee and Halladay would not have let that happen. Unable to move
Joe Blanton and his contract at winter meetings, and burdened with a
Jamie Moyer contract for 2010 that will be impossible to move, the only real option that would satisfy the needs of the team's budget and minor league system was to find a suitor for Lee.
The Seattle Mariners were that team. The Mariners have made some drastic moves to improve their team for the 2010 season and Lee may be the crown jewel of the off-season acquisitions for the AL West squad. The Mariners also signed Chone Figgins away from the rival Anaheim Angels and appear to be ready to make a run at the AL West title this upcoming season.
The deal is finally done. It may take some time for people to move past losing Lee, who was brilliant in the postseason. Lee's dominance of the Rockies, Dodgers and Yankees left a promising lasting image that Phillies fans had expected to see continue in 2010.
It will. Just with a different pitcher.
Read more...